The Philip Glass – Steve Reich thing aka the feud


For a Nonesuch Celebration at BAM, Reich and Glass Bury the Hatchet

by Allan Kozinn, May 12, 2014

NY Times

Among the biggest surprises, and a measure of the regard in which the label is held in musical circles: Steve Reich and Musicians and the Philip Glass Ensemble will be sharing a program, something they haven’t done since the 1970s, when they apparently had a falling out that each has consistently refused to comment on publicly. The two ensembles will play three programs (Sept. 9-11) that will include many of their major works, including Mr. Reich’s “Drumming” and “Music for 18 Musicians,” and excerpts from Mr. Glass’s “Einstein on the Beach,” “Koyaanisqatsi” and “Music in 12 Parts.”

The Philip Glass – Steve Reich thing aka the feud

Steve Reich on Philip Glass: By early 1968, he had done a piece called One Plus One. And One Plus One was to Phil what It’s Gonna Rain was to me. It was his first original musical insight – the additive process. After that, he wrote a piece which he dedicated to me, but later took the dedication away. It was called Two Pages for Steve Reich, but is now Two Pages, subtitled Music in Unison. Basically, what happened between Phil and me was very much the kind of thing that had happened to me with Riley, which is a lot of things are floating around in your mind and somebody comes along who really sets things straight. The difference is that, for whatever reasons, he has been unwilling to admit that. And that has been one source of grief between us, for sure. I don’t quite understand, will all the success that he’s had, why that remains something he’s very uptight about. But those things happened; they are documented in programs, reviews, and scores. It’s not conjecture.

La Monte Young: …according to Steve, Phil and Steve had a group together, and Phil began to play the way he does after he was in a group with Steve.

William Duckworth: Everybody seems to have different stories about what happened.

La Monte Young: Well, Phil claims to come out of a vacuum. Nobody ever existed according to his book. At least that’s what I understand.

William Duckworth: What’s your interpretation of all this?

La Monte Young: Well, the story I tell is that there’s only one concert that I know of where all four of us appeared together. This was a concert that was put on by a group at Yale called Pulsa. They were doing a lot of work with light and…

Marian Zazeela: A lot of art and technology stuff…

La Monte Young: the concert was in 19…

Marian Zazeela: …I think it was ’67 or ’68…

La Monte Young: …and it was all tapes. I played a tape of Map of 49’s Dream—very sophisticated La Monte Young. Terry Riley probably played some of that two-tape recorder stuff he recorded with a saxophone—very clearly Terry Riley. And Steve Reich was sounding like Steve Reich. But Phil Glass played a piece that just sounded like a single line. It was either a violin or a saxophone.

Marian Zazeela: It was a violin.

La Monte Young: …and it just went on and on. It was incredibly dull. There was none of what you would call minimalism going on at all. Now OK, maybe it wasn’t a representative work. I don’t know. All I know is that’s what he played. Later on, I heard him…

Marian Zazeela: It must have been in the early ‘70s.

La Monte Young: …and there he was; he had a new sound. I don’t know what happened, but that was my experience. Now, maybe it wasn’t a characteristic piece. Maybe he had other pieces hidden away in 1968 that were just full of this minimal stuff. I don’t know,

From Talking Music by William Duckworth, 1995

Update August 21, 2014

Seth Colter Walls (TimeOut NY): You’re reuniting on a stage with Glass for the first time in decades. In between, there’s been a lot of talk about a feud, and hurt feelings. Too much talk?

Steve Reich: Well, look. This is Nonesuch’s 50th birthday. Bob called me up and said, “I’d like you to come and have lunch with me and Phil Glass.” And I said, “I’d love to!” And I’m sure he did the same with Phil. Actually, Phil and I had seen each other about a month before that, at a lunch—a kind of a homage to the Kronos Quartet, who had their 25th anniversary. People who had worked with them—both Phil and myself—were giving testimonials to how great they were. But the lunch, the idea, this whole [Nonesuch Records at BAM] project is Bob Hurwitz’s idea. And it’s a great one, and so here we are.

more from this recent interview here.

1 comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Microtonal Projects' BLOG

we promote, research, perform and educate

Musica Kaleidoskopea

a kaleidoscopic view of music

The Canterbury scene(zine) continued....

Random ramblings nearly 30 years further on from a Canterbury scene veteran

David Beardsley

microtonal guitarist and composer

The Hum Blog

a blog for

Luminiferous Aether Drift

This massless business

J.C. Combs

acoustic and electronic arts

Ted Greene Archive

Immortalizing Beauty Through Music

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

New Music Buff

Random perspectives from an informed new music fan.

Night After Night

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

The Watchful Ear

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Field Stations and Outposts of Anaphoria Island

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Make Your Own Taste

Eclectic reviews of ambient, psychedelic, post-rock, folk and progressive rock ... etc.!

Articulate Silences

Tacet / Tacet / Tacet

David Rothenberg

musician, composer, author and philosopher-naturalist


Scott Healy's Jazz Composition Blog: Writing, Arranging and Listening

Avant Music News

A source for news on music that is challenging, interesting, different, progressive, introspective, or just plain weird

Do The Math

thoughts about music by David Beardsley


Just another site

Music : NPR

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

destination: OUT

thoughts about music by David Beardsley


thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Renewable Music

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Miniatures Blog

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Mixed Meters

thoughts about music by David Beardsley


thoughts about music by David Beardsley

Bob Gluck's Blog

Just another site

Today Is The Question: Ted Panken on Music, Politics and the Arts

My thoughts and writings on jazz and the world around it.


a sinister resonance


Kyle Gann on music after the fact

%d bloggers like this: